It does that sometimes for whatever reason. If you run a shallow and he dive catches and you run it again, it'll do it again.
Playbook seems fine. Put the rest of it together and start an OD. Invite me tomorrow and we can see if it works. Not sure what the issue was with the test OD, but it seemed wonky from the start. I couldn't select a custom playbook when I created my coach.
You had horrible fumble luck that game Never seen it that bad