Since when is Piscataway a reel city? Just because you fly in and out of New York doesn’t mean you’re in NYC.
If you are looking for best game day experiences as a traveling fan, it’s probably Nebraska or Iowa. Maybe Wisconsin, but they’re as friendly as those 2. Michigan, OSU, Penn State are all fun, too. Indiana and Northwestern are basically home games, but I’d put Indiana a notch above Northwestern because Bloomington is better than Evanston. Minnesota isn’t a great game day experience, but Minneapolis is fun. Rutgers, Maryland, Illinois, MSU, and Purdue all suck.